National FHA assistance
Up to 3.5% or 5%
Minimum credit score: 600 FICO with automated underwriting approval. Confirm the manual-underwriting minimum for this option.
Pairs with an FHA purchase loan.
Repayable second mortgage: The rate is 1 percentage point above the first mortgage rate. Monthly payments cover principal and interest and pay off the second mortgage over 10 years.
Forgivable second mortgage: 0% interest and no monthly payment on the second mortgage. The balance can be forgiven after 36 consecutive, on-time payments on the FHA first mortgage. Ask what happens if a payment is late or the first mortgage is paid off early.
FHA assistance with a three-year residency condition
Up to 3.5% or 5%
Minimum credit score: 600 FICO with automated underwriting approval. The comparison sheet also lists 600 for manual underwriting, subject to current lender confirmation.
Pairs with an FHA purchase loan.
Repayable second mortgage: The Michigan rate shown on the sheet is 2 percentage points above the first mortgage rate. Monthly payments cover principal and interest and pay off the second mortgage over 10 years.
Forgivable second mortgage: 0% interest and no monthly payment on the second mortgage. The balance can be forgiven three years after the note date if the home remains your primary residence and no event requiring repayment has occurred. Ask which events would trigger repayment.
Conventional assistance
Up to 4%
Minimum credit score: 660 FICO with automated underwriting approval. This option requires automated underwriting.
Pairs with a conventional purchase loan. The percentage is based on the lower of the purchase price or appraised value.
Repayable second mortgage: The rate matches the first mortgage rate. The second mortgage has a 30-year term with interest-only monthly payments. Scheduled payments leave the principal balance outstanding. The unpaid principal comes due in full at sale, refinance, transfer, maturity or early payoff of the first mortgage.
Manual underwriting and homebuyer education
- National FHA assistance: The comparison sheet requires homebuyer education for scores of 600–639.
- FHA assistance with a three-year residency condition: At least one borrower must complete homebuyer education.
- Conventional assistance: All borrowers must complete homebuyer education.
Manual underwriting means a lender reviews the file under a separate set of rules. Confirm the current score requirement for the exact program before using these figures. The comparison sheet lists 600 for manual underwriting on both FHA options. Kind Lending’s public National FHA assistance materials list 660 for manual underwriting. See Kind Lending’s published terms.
These scores apply to the assistance programs. The first mortgage has its own credit rules. Property, occupancy and education requirements also vary. Conventional assistance has income limits that depend on the loan program and area median income.
What would a $10,000 second mortgage cost each month?
For illustration, assume a 6% first mortgage rate and a $10,000 second mortgage. The National FHA repayable second would be about $116 per month at 7% for 10 years. The other FHA repayable second would be about $121 per month at 8% for 10 years. The conventional second would be $50 per month at 6% in interest, with the $10,000 principal still due if you make only the scheduled interest payments.
These are second-mortgage payments only. The rates are illustrative. Ask for the rate, payment, payoff triggers and forgiveness terms in writing for the option you’re considering.